the 50's staging could have worked, but in this instance the strength of the male lead was unable to deliver. I have (measurably) better hearing than most people, so I enjoy live music over recorded almost without exception, always feel closer to the music, performer and composer in a live venue.
But try as I might, there were times the male lead's voice just dropped out of hearing range, I was middle distance - I'm certain he was enunciating but the volume just wasn't there. No goofs, he knows the part, but his voice has some growing to do.
I'm always very reluctant to criticise someone who clearly has a talent I cannot fathom - but this is one case where I overcome my reluctance. I attend opera to take my heart to places that bring a rush of emotion as I become wrapped up in the voice - the Male suitor to Elvira was a champ, Elvira and Anna - both brought tears and helped rescue the production.
The theatre and staff, as always, deliver with a minimum of fuss and proper decorum. I wish I could rate this higher - but the restaging and the weak male lead just dont work in this instance, regardless, in another ten years the male lead will be up to it - I'll look forward to it.