Of the shows we've seen over the last couple years at Shea's (Rent, Wicked, Chorus Line, Avenue Q, Jesus Christ Superstar) this was the second most disappointing. Not to say that it was a bad production but it was lacking. The cast as a whole was vocally uninspiring in song (a few showed flashes like the actress playing Tzietel), the choreography would have been fine for a high school production but not a national touring company. Too many of the characters stayed at simple one dimensional portrayals. The actor playing Tevye handled the comedy quite well but his singing was short of the standard and his movement was likewise. Several key scenes (like the visit from Frumasarah) lost much of their punch because of the vocal shortcomings of the cast.
The staging was outstanding and the show itself is good enough to make for an adequate evening at the theater.
The worst show we ever saw at Shea's was the recent Jesus Christ Superstar which was simply awful due to the poor casting in the lead role. This show is leagues better than that but was still quite disappointing.