"Aspects of Love" is one of those curiosities from Andrew Lloyd Webber that people either loved or loathed. I loved it when I saw it on Broadway in 1990 and ended up seeing it seven times! Twenty years later the show was presented at the Walnut Street Theater in a very satisfying production that I would highly recommend. Was it as good as the Broadway production? Of course not. Was it better than the Robin Phillips-directed debacle that toured in 93? Hell, yes!
The choice to make George a bit younger and spry was a good one and Paul Shoeffler was one of the most appealing aspects of the shoe. Rose, the leading lady who drove every man insane, was played by Jennifer Hope Wills and was truly enchanting. Alex was played by Charles Hagerty and while his singing voice was astounding, I found this version of the character a bit offputting, even sinister (especially in the second act).
I am one of those people who knows the show so well that I can tell when a line of dialogue has been changed or ommitted altogether, as happened fairly often in this production which is not a detriment, by and large.
Turning "Love Changes Everthing" into an ensemble piece at the opening was a good idea (rather than have Alex sing it as a solo) as it bonded the characters very early on. The second act wasn't nearly as strong as the first and I found the deletion of the harvest scene disappointing. The circus scene simply didn't work for me. The audience had no idea that the characters were going to the circus for Jenny's birthday and the circus performers were costumed like the touring company of the Rocky Horror Show. Still having nightmares about the half man/half woman "clown" with a small lamp extending from his Mad Hatter top had and shining right in his/her face...um, what?
Did NOT like the adjustments to the score for "Hand Me the Wine & the Dice." The tune lost a lot of its power. I should also add that the young actresses play Jenny at different ages were a bit, um, wanting. Very awkward. When Jenny aged two years in the orchestral interlude, it would've made more sense to have the actresses wearing the same dress. I know for a fact the audience was confused by this scene.
All in all it was a great theatrical experience and I commend Walnut Street Theater for presenting this lost gem!